Watch Les jeux sont faits (1947)
French Film, Drama, Fanatsy
English title: The Chips are Down
Cannes Film Festival, 1947- Official Selection
In the immediate aftermath of World War II, French existentialism found one of its most compelling cinematic expressions not in a dry philosophical treatise, but in a supernatural noir titled Les jeux sont faits (1947). Directed by Jean Delannoy with a screenplay penned by Jean-Paul Sartre, the film serves as a haunting exploration of destiny, social division, and the agonizing weight of human freedom. More on Wikipedia or Mubi
The narrative follows two protagonists from opposite ends of the social spectrum: Eve Charlier, a wealthy socialite poisoned by her treacherous husband, and Pierre Dumaine, a rugged revolutionary leader assassinated by a militia informant. They meet for the first time in a ghostly, monochromatic version of Paris—a limbo where the dead wander unseen among the living. In this ethereal bureaucracy, they discover that they were "soulmates" who missed their chance on earth due to the accidents of class and timing.
Through a cosmic loophole, they are granted a second chance at life. They are sent back to the world of the living with one condition: they must prove, within twenty-four hours, that they can love each other unconditionally and prioritize their bond over all other earthly preoccupations.
The title, which translates to "the chips are down" or "the stakes are set," refers to the finality of a gambler’s bet, and it underscores Sartre’s central preoccupation with the permanence of our choices. Once Eve and Pierre return to their bodies, they are immediately pulled back into the gravity of their previous lives. Pierre is consumed by the need to prevent a doomed uprising and save his comrades, while Eve is desperate to protect her sister from her murderous husband.
Delannoy utilizes sharp contrasts in cinematography to highlight the tragedy of their situation. The fluidity of the afterlife, where the characters are free from material consequence, stands in stark opposition to the claustrophobic, high-stakes tension of the physical world. Despite their genuine affection for one another, the protagonists find that "existence precedes essence" is a difficult burden to carry. They are defined not by their abstract potential as soulmates, but by the concrete actions they take in a world that demands their loyalty.
Ultimately, Les jeux sont faits is a profound meditation on the limitations of the human condition. It suggests that while we are free to choose, we are never free from the context of our world or the responsibilities we have created. The film remains a landmark of French cinema, blending the atmospheric dread of a thriller with the intellectual rigor of one of the 20th century’s most influential thinkers. It leaves the audience with the sobering realization that while love may be eternal in the shadows, it must survive the relentless ticking of the clock in the light of day.
The Good: Why It’s a Classic
A Brilliant Philosophical Hook: The premise is peak Sartre. It explores the idea that "the die is cast" (les jeux sont faits) once we die, but poses a "what if" scenario about human agency. It’s a compelling "metaphysical thriller" that asks whether we are truly free or just prisoners of our past choices.
Atmospheric World-Building: The film excels in its depiction of the afterlife. Rather than a surreal or religious heaven/hell, the dead simply walk among the living as invisible observers. This creates a haunting, melancholic atmosphere as the protagonists watch their loved ones betray them or move on without them.
Micheline Presle’s Performance: As Eve, the wealthy woman poisoned by her husband, Micheline Presle provides a radiant and sophisticated presence. Critics often cite her as the highlight of the film, bringing emotional weight to the somewhat rigid philosophical script.
Political Relevance: Coming just two years after the end of WWII, the film’s subplots—involving an underground resistance movement and a corrupt "Regent"—resonated deeply with a French audience still processing the Occupation and the Resistance.
The Bad: Where It Falters
Stiff Direction: Jean Delannoy was a practitioner of what French New Wave critics later called the "Tradition of Quality." While the film is technically polished, it can feel "stuffy" or overly formal. Compared to the more fluid, experimental styles emerging at the time, some find the direction a bit uninspired.
Lack of Romantic Chemistry: While the actors are talented individually, many viewers feel a lack of "spark" between the two leads (Micheline Presle and Marcello Pagliero). Since the plot hinges on their world-defying love, the lack of palpable chemistry can make the stakes feel lower than they should be.
Heavy-Handed Dialogue: Because it was written by a philosopher to illustrate specific theories (like "Bad Faith" and "Freedom"), the dialogue occasionally feels more like a lecture than a natural conversation. It prioritizes the "message" over the human drama.
Predictability: For some, the ending feels inevitable from the start. If you are familiar with Sartre’s philosophy (e.g., No Exit), you might find that the film’s cynical outlook on human nature makes the plot feel like a foregone conclusion.
Full Film (English subtitles)
Comments
Post a Comment