Bulldog Drummond (1929) Review: The Good, The Bad & How to Watch

Bulldog Drummond (1929) Review: The Good, The Bad & How to Watch

American Film, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Romance

Early All-Talkie Film
Academy Awards, 1930–2 nominations, including: Best Actor in a Leading Role
National Board of Review, 1929- Winner: Top Ten Films
Box office Hit
Critical Acclaim 

Bulldog Drummond (1929) is a significant film in cinematic history, not only for being one of the first sound films, but also for introducing the classic detective character to the big screen. The film's success helped establish the popular character's longevity in film.

The film stars Ronald Colman as Captain Hugh "Bulldog" Drummond, a bored, wealthy British soldier returning from World War I who craves adventure. He places a classified ad in a newspaper seeking "excitement." This leads him to a plea for help from a young woman, Phyllis Clavering (played by Joan Bennett), whose uncle, a scientist, has been kidnapped by a criminal gang led by the nefarious Carl Peterson. Drummond, along with his loyal associate Algy Longworth, takes on the case. The plot unfolds as a classic detective story, featuring disguises, a high-stakes car chase, and a thrilling confrontation at the villain's hideout. More on Wikipedia or Mubi

The star

Ronald Colman's portrayal of Bulldog Drummond is often praised for capturing the character's debonair charm and wit. He plays Drummond as a refined man who nonetheless possesses a taste for danger and a knack for solving mysteries. Colman's performance earned him an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor, a testament to his skill and the film's success. He was nominated for his roles in Bulldog Drummond and Condemned, becoming the first actor to receive a dual nomination.

Significance

Bulldog Drummond (1929) stands out as a pioneering effort in the early sound era of film. It was the first "talking" film for United Artists and one of the first major pictures to fully utilize synchronized dialogue, music, and sound effects. The film's use of sound was innovative for its time, with scenes that relied heavily on spoken dialogue rather than title cards. This marked a major step away from silent films and toward the narrative style we know today.

The film's success cemented Bulldog Drummond as a cinematic character, leading to a long series of films and a radio show. It established the template for the debonair British adventurer archetype that would later be seen in characters like James Bond. The film's legacy lies in its role as a bridge between two eras of filmmaking, and its successful introduction of an iconic literary hero to a wider audience.

What is good in the film

• A masterful transition to sound: For a film produced so early in the sound era, Bulldog Drummond is a surprisingly polished production. Unlike many of its contemporaries, which often felt like filmed stage plays, it makes effective use of sound to enhance the storytelling. The audio is clear, the dialogue feels natural, and the inclusion of sound effects helps build atmosphere and tension.

• Ronald Colman's performance: This film is a showcase for Ronald Colman's charisma and voice. Having been a silent film star, his seamless transition to a "talkie" proved his versatility and cemented his stardom. He brings a debonair charm and a playful wit to the title role, a personality that would later influence the portrayal of other British heroes like James Bond. His performance earned him an Academy Award nomination.

• Art direction and cinematography: The film boasts impressive production values for its time, with notable work from art director William Cameron Menzies and cinematographers George Barnes and Gregg Toland. The use of low-key lighting and expressive shadows, influenced by German Expressionism, creates a dark and suspenseful mood, particularly in the villain's hideout.

• A fast-paced narrative: The film moves at a brisk pace, with a classic detective plot that keeps the viewer engaged. It features a number of thrilling elements like a car chase and a confrontation at a remote sanatorium, all of which were exciting for audiences of the time.

What is not so good in the film

• Pacing and staging issues: While the overall narrative is fast-paced, some scenes, particularly those with a lot of dialogue, can feel a bit static and "stage-bound" to a modern audience. This is a common characteristic of many early talkies, as filmmakers were still figuring out how to use the camera effectively with sound recording equipment.

• The "silly ass" sidekick: The character of Algy, Drummond's friend and sidekick, is often cited as a weakness. Played by Claud Allister, the character is a stereotypical "upper-class twit" meant for comic relief. His antics can be seen as overly broad and, for some viewers, a bit tiresome.

• Over-the-top villainy: The villains, including the nefarious Carl Peterson and the sadistic Dr. Lakington, are portrayed in a very melodramatic, almost cartoonish way. This type of performance was typical of the silent era and the early days of sound, but it can feel dated and lack the subtlety of more modern portrayals.

• Simple plot and character development: The plot is fairly straightforward, without the complex twists and psychological depth that audiences might expect from a modern thriller. The characters, especially the damsel in distress Phyllis, are not particularly nuanced.

In conclusion, Bulldog Drummond is a film that's best appreciated as a pioneering work. While some of its conventions feel a bit archaic today, it's a fascinating look at the birth of the sound era, and Ronald Colman's star-making performance and the film's technical achievements make it a classic worth revisiting.
Full Film