The Ghost Goes West (1935) Review: The Good, The Bad & How to Watch
British Film, Fantasy, Comedy, Romance
Venice Film Festival, 1936- Official Selection
National Board of Review, 1936- Winner: Top Foreign Films
When French director René Clair crossed the English Channel to make his first British film, nobody quite expected him to deliver a comedy that would feel so undeniably American in its spirit. The result was The Ghost Goes West, a delightful 1935 satirical fantasy that took a gentle, witty jab at the clash between old-world Scottish tradition and new-world American commercialism. More on Wikipedia or Mubi
A Ghost That Conquered America
The story kicks off in the rugged, misty highlands of Scotland, where Murdoch Glourie, a dashing but somewhat cowardly 18th-century Scotsman, dies in a ridiculous explosion of gunpowder. Because he failed to avenge an insult to his family name, Murdoch is doomed to haunt his ancestral castle until he can find a way to redeem his honor. Fast forward to the modern era of the 1930s, and his descendant, Donald Glourie, finds himself drowning in debt. Enter Peggy Martin, a wealthy and charming American heiress, along with her mega-rich businessman father.
Seeing an opportunity that only a true capitalist could dream up, the elder Martin buys the entire historic castle, stones and all. His grand plan is to dismantle the fortress piece by piece, pack it into crates, and ship it across the Atlantic to be rebuilt in sunny Florida.
What the Americans don't realize is that the castle comes with its original inhabitant. Murdoch the ghost hitches a ride to the United States, and that is where the movie truly finds its comedic stride.
Robert Donat pulls off a brilliant double duty here, playing both the modern, stressed-out Donald and the romantic, slightly confused ghost Murdoch. Donat brings a wonderful charm to both roles, making it easy to see why American audiences fell in love with the film upon its release. The scenes where the phantom wanders through jazz-age America, terrified yet fascinated by modern technology, are filled with the kind of whimsical, visual humor that Clair was famous for.
The heart of the movie lies in its playful mockery of American consumer culture. To the wealthy buyers, history is just another commodity that can be bought, sold, and relocated for entertainment. Yet, Clair never lets the satire get bitter. Instead, it plays out as a warm, romantic comedy where love bridges the gap between a penniless Scottish laird, a ghost looking for peace, and a modern American family.
The Ghost Goes West became a massive hit on both sides of the Atlantic, proving that a story about Scottish ghosts and American dollars had a universal appeal that still holds up as a classic piece of cinematic escapism.
What Makes It Shine, and Where It Fades
Looking back at The Ghost Goes West, it remains a fascinating slice of 1930s cinema that captures a very specific moment in filmmaking history. While it was a massive crowd-pleaser upon its initial release, viewing it today reveals a mix of brilliant cinematic flourishes alongside some elements that haven't aged quite as gracefully.
The Good
The absolute brightest spot of the film is Robert Donat. Fresh off his success in Alfred Hitchcock’s The 39 Steps, Donat handles the dual roles of the stressed modern descendant and the romantic 18th-century ghost with absolute perfection. He gives the phantom Murdoch a gentle, poetic melancholy that makes him incredibly endearing, rather than spooky.
René Clair’s transition to English-language cinema also brought a refreshing European sensibility to the production. His background in silent film means the visual storytelling is incredibly strong. The movie relies heavily on clever sight gags, expressive acting, and a whimsical atmosphere rather than just heavy dialogue. The culture clash between Scottish stoicism and loud, booming American commercialism is handled with a light, satirical touch that feels affectionate rather than mean-spirited. For its time, the special effects used to make Donat appear transparent were also quite impressive and added to the magical, fairy-tale quality of the story.
The Bad
On the flip side, the film’s pacing can feel a bit uneven to modern audiences. The first half, set in Scotland, moves at a wonderful, atmospheric clip, but once the castle actually moves to America, the narrative engine slows down. The satirical jokes about American millionaires and jazz culture, while biting and hilarious in 1935, can feel a bit dated and repetitive today.
The romantic subplot also lacks the spark you might expect from a classic screwball comedy. Jean Parker is charming enough as the American heiress Peggy, but her character is written with fairly thin motivations, serving more as a plot device to link the two worlds together rather than a fully realized person. Additionally, viewers looking for a genuine supernatural thrill or a deeper exploration of the ghost's centuries-long isolation might find the film a bit too lightweight, as it consistently chooses safe, wholesome comedy over any real dramatic tension.
Ultimately, it stands as a light, breezy caper. It may not possess the tight plotting of modern comedies, but its historical charm and Donat's dual performance still offer plenty of reasons to smile.
Comments
Post a Comment